Banner
Defiance
Category Action , Military/War
Year: 2008
Time: 137 minutes
Production: Paramount Vantage
Director: Edward Zwick
Cast:
Daniel Craig, Liev Schreiber, Jamie Bell, Jodhi May
MPAA R / UK15
Our Rating 5/10
Watchability 6/10
Contributed by Jordan Taylor
 
Plot:

The two eldest Bielski brothers (Daniel Craig and Liev Schreiber) return to their parents' farm in Belarus to find they have been murdered by Nazis and cooperating villagers.  With their two youngest brothers they take to the woods, and it is not long before hundreds of Jews that have escaped the death squads join them for protection. With constant pressure to supply food for the people in their care, and Nazi patrols about to find their camp, they have a choice to die fighting or try to survive each passing day living by faith.

 
So, how does it end?

In their base over the cold winter months, they have a strong community spirit and more join their number from neighboring ghettos. Tuvia reclaims his leadership by shooting dead an insurgent, organized patrols bring in food, and they even have time for classes.

When Spring approaches, Zus (who is still with the Red Army) learns that the Germans are planning a full scale attack on the forest - but that his commander is going to leave the Jews to their death. If he doesn't leave with them, he will be shot.

The youngest brother somehow captures a huge German soldier, and from his papers the Jews in the forest learn that the attack is imminent. Tuvia for the first time begins to doubt the people in his care when some of them attack the German like a pack of animals -- something he has always tried to avoid.

A spy plane flies overhead - followed by bombers that destroy their forest camp and scatter the people. They quickly make their way out as the infantry will soon be approaching. Those left behind to defend their escape don't last very long.

Tuvia leads the people out the forest to a great lake. Taking his cue from Moses, they hold hands and make their way out through the strong currents.

They make it safely to the other side (all except the old school teacher who dies of fatigue), but can't relax for long as a Panzer division approaches and opens fire. Tuzia and the academic outflank the platoon and steal a machine gun, but are trapped and the academic kills himself as he can't throw the grenade very far.

Suddenly, Zus leads his men out behind the Germans and with their better military expertise kill the remaining troops, and throw a grenade inside the tank. Zus asks to rejoin his brother's mission, and he gladly accepts.

As it ends, they enter another forest and the credits tell us that 1200 survived two more years of hiding - and in the new camp they even opened a school and a hospital. Later, Tuvia and Zus moved to New York where they started a trucking company, the middle-younger brother (Jamie Bell) joined the Red Army but died 6 months later. The number of children and grandchildren from those that survived now numbers in the tens of thousands, but the Bielskis have never sought credit. (The other side to the story and possible reason is that Tuvia's men were just as bad as the Germans, but that wouldn't have made as good a movie)

 
Notes
The Russian accents are just confusing -- there are whole scenes where it's pretty difficult to work out what is being said. And then they talk in Russian with subtitles to others - it would have been better to just use natural accents and the audience can guess whether people in Belarus talk in English or Belarusian(?). A few super-imposed maps might have helped in the credits, or while they were planning their escape, to show where they were heading - not many people (myself included) can pinpoint Belarus on a map straight-off!
Vote:
 
6.25/10 ( 4 Votes )
Hits: 21632
Trailer: 0 (coming soon) Reviews: 0 (email us!) Comments: (see below)

In cinemas now In cinemas now...
Despicable Me 3 Despicable Me 3
Gru is fired from the Anti-Villain League when 80s-inspired Super Villain Balthazar Bratt steal a priceless diamond, and he takes the blame.  But when an elderly gentlemen shows up at his door to inform Gru that he has a long-lost twin brother, who is desperate to become a villa...
Cars 3 Cars 3
Lightning McQueen has enjoyed great success in the Piston Cup, but a new breed of racecar, led by the quick Jackson Storm are threatening to disrupt racing, forcing many cars into early retirement. Lightning refuses to give up, and with the help of old and new friends, is determi...

Other movies Check out: